Can Boxer Dogs Drink Milk?

Your Boxer won’t drop dead from stealing a few laps of milk from your glass, but there is no reason to deliberately have your dog drink milk.

Dogs have no biological requirement for the milk of another species.

This means milk is not necessary in a dog’s diet — and the nutrients it contains are readily provided by other, more species-appropriate foods.


This post is for general informational and educational purposes only. I encourage readers to see my full disclaimer here.


Why Milk Is Not Recommended For Boxer Dogs

Allergies

Dogs can be allergic to milk and to the milk by-products contained in many processed foods.

In her book Canine Nutrigenomics, veterinarian Jean Dodds rules cow’s milk out as a healthy food for dogs for multiple reasons.

For a start, it is “highly antigenic” for dogs — in other words, it’s likely to trigger an allergic reaction.

In some dogs, milk causes:

  • Stomach upset
  • Skin problems
  • Diarrhea

Lactose Intolerance

Some dogs, like some people, don’t produce the enzyme lactase once they’ve finished weaning.

This means they cannot digest lactose (milk sugar).

The undigested lactose is converted by bacteria in the gut into volatile fatty acids, hydrogen gas and carbon dioxide.

These by-products are very acidic, irritating the bowel. Because of this, water is not reabsorbed from the bowel like it usually is.

Frothy, smelly diarrhea is the result.

A1 Protein

There is a third issue with milk, associated with a genetically mutated protein known as A1 beta-casein that is found in much of the modern day milk supply.

All cows originally produced milk containing A2 beta-casein.

These days, however, about half the cows in the United States produce milk containing the A1 version of this protein.

Even organic and raw milk contains this A1 protein.

A1 cows include breeds commonly seen in western countries like Holstein, Friesian and Jersey cows.

These breeds have proliferated because they produce more milk than their A1 counterparts, which are the lesser known breeds like Gir and Sahiwal native to India.

A1 protein is that it digests differently, releasing a peptide called beta-casomorphin-7 (BCM7), an opioid with characteristics similar to morphine.

This peptide can cross from the stomach into the bloodstream, provoking an autoimmune response and triggering inflammation.

Though not everyone agrees A1 protein is a problem, in his 2009 book, agricultural scientist Keith Woodford called A1 “the milk devil”, citing more than 100 peer-reviewed papers indicating that A1 beta-casein might be responsible for autoimmune diseases including heat disease and diabetes.

Fat

Milk is also quite fatty, upping the overall fat content of your dog’s diet.

This is not something most pet dogs need, since they already arguably consume more fat than they should.

Wild dogs eat lean game meats, as opposed to the deliberately fattened livestock which the majority of pet dogs consume.

Raw Vs. Pasteurized, Homogenized Milk For Boxer Dogs

If you’re going to feed milk to your dog, it will be more worthwhile if you choose raw, unpasteurized milk.

Pasteurization uses heat to destroy pathogens and extend shelf life but it also destroys:

  • B vitamins including riboflavin (vitamin B2)
  • Vitamin C
  • Antioxidants
  • Enzymes including lactase (which helps digest lactose) and other longevity factors

Pasteurization also denatures protein, making it less bioavailable

In his book Give Your Dog a Bone, Dr Ian Billinghurst says giving a dog pasteurized milk is “about as good as feeding any other cooked food”.

In order words, it’s unnatural.

Most milk is also homogenized.

Homogenization mixes and disperses the fat in milk using a high-pressure procedure to break it into smaller particles that then remain suspended, giving the milk a more uniform consistency.

Unfortunately, homogenization also releases a chemical that damages blood vessel walls, contributing to cardiovascular disease.

Alternatives To Milk As A Source Of Nutrients For Dogs

Calcium

If you are wanting to give milk for its calcium content, there are far more biologically appropriate sources for a dog.

Raw meaty bones are how dogs are meant to receive their calcium (and their phosphorus).

If you feed a natural, canine diet based on raw meaty bones, there is no need to supplement or tinker with calcium levels.

Your dog will be getting the right amount.

If, for some reason, you are needing to add calcium, eggs shells ground to a powder in a clean coffee grinder are a better option than milk.

Note: Intact eggshells given when feeding whole raw eggs are fine to feed but may not provide much calcium since they’re often not digested, especially if you’re noticing egg shell in the poop.

Vitamin A

Milk offers vitamin A.

However, liver and egg yolk are two more species-appropriate sources of vitamin A for dogs that will already be in your Boxer’s diet if you’re raw feeding.

Check out our Beginner’s Guide To Raw Feeding A Boxer

Milk Substitute For Orphaned Boxer Puppies

Goat’s Milk

Goat’s milk has been successfully used as a milk substitute with young pups.

More on goat’s milk below.

Milk With Added Egg

Dr Billinghurst, who also breeds Rottweilers and Great Danes, recommends the following recipe as an “excellent emergency substitute milk for orphan pups”:

  • 1 cup cow’s milk
  • 2 egg yolks
  • 1-2 teaspoons canola oil
  • 1 teaspoon honey
  • small pinch salt
  • few drops complete vitamin supplement

In his experience, cow’s milk augmented in this way rarely causes the diarrhea and other issues often seen with plain cow’s milk.

The theory is this has something to do with the fact that adding protein and fat to the milk, in the form of the raw egg:

  • Dilutes the lactose
  • Returns the milk to a more species-appropriate nutrient profile (similar to the milk puppies drink from their mothers)

(Dog’s milk is twice as concentrated as cow’s milk, containing double the energy, protein and fat, but the same amount of lactose.)

If You Must Give Your Adult Boxer Milk

If you are determined to give milk to your Boxer, milk sourced from sheep or goats is likely to cause him fewer problems.

Most dogs tolerate these milks well.

Goat’s milk is raw and still contains its own enzymes, which usually means even lactose-intolerant dogs can handle it better than cow’s milk.

Likewise, dogs allergic to cow’s milk generally drink goat’s milk without problems.

Goat’s milk:

  • Contains only A2 protein
  • Has less fat than cow’s milk
  • Has more sodium and potassium than cow’s milk
  • Produces a more alkaline reaction in the stomach (alkalinity is more health producing than acidity)
  • Forms a softer, more easily digested curd
  • May have a better fatty acid balance
  • Has more digestible fat with finer globules and natural homogenization
  • Has better prebiotic properties than cow’s milk thanks to non-digestible sugars called oligosaccharides that feed gut probiotics

On the downside, goat’s milk:

  • Has less calcium and protein than cow’s milk
  • Contains no beta-carotene i.e. no vitamin A
  • Has very low levels of folic acid and vitamin B6

Organic, grass-fed milk of all kinds is preferable to conventionally farmed products because it contains:

  • A healthier balance of omega-3 to omega-6 fatty acids
  • Fewer saturated fatty acids
  • More protein
  • No antibiotics, GMOs (because the stock aren’t fed or medicated with these) and fewer pesticides

Should Boxers Eat Other Dairy Products?

Though your Boxer has no need for milk, whether he should eat other dairy products is less clear cut.

As processed foods, dairy products don’t figure in a completely natural canine diet.

Ice Cream

Sweetened dairy foods like ice cream are basically frozen confectionery and not appropriate for your dog.

Cottage Cheese

However, Dr Billinghurst does recommend cottage cheese on account of the fact it contains three essential amino acids (leucine, isoleucine and valine) that are said to aid wound healing and help build muscle.

Yoghurt And Cheese

Yoghurt and cheese do not contain lactose, which is good for lactose intolerant dogs but also means the calcium in these products is less well absorbed, as lactose plays a role in helping the body access calcium.

Dr Billinghurst sees a place for plain, natural yoghurt (not the sweetened varieties) in a dog’s diet.

He says it can stand in for the consumption of feces, something wild dogs do but a behavior we rarely let our pets engage in.

With its living culture of bacteria, yoghurt provides a truckload of bacteria that can help normalize the bowel microflora.

In addition, yoghurt contains:

  • Calcium, in large amounts
  • Quality protein
  • Vitamins including B vitamins and vitamin A
  • Enzymes

Is Soy Milk Okay For Boxer Dogs?

In short, no.

Soy milk:

  • Is likely to come from GMO crops
  • Is likely to contain more pesticide than other milks
  • Tends to be poorly digested
  • Has a poor amino acid profile
  • Contains phytates that bind to calcium, preventing its absorption

Conclusion

Your Boxer doesn’t need milk in his diet and can get the same nutrients from more biologically appropriate sources like raw meaty bones.

Cow’s milk can cause allergic reactions, stomach upset due to lactose intolerance and even autoimmune issues and inflammation due to the presence of A1 protein.

Goat’s milk can be useful for young pups needing a milk substitute.

Dairy products like cottage cheese and plain, natural yoghurt may offer more beneficial additions to your adult Boxer’s diet.

References

Calcium in Homemade Dog Food, Mary Strauss, Whole Dog Journal, 2019

Canine Nutrigenomics – The New Science of Feeding Your Dog for Optimum Health, W Jean Dodds, DVM and Diane R Laverdure, Dogwise Publishing, 2015

Give Your Dog a Bone, Dr Ian Billinghurst, 1993

The Devil in the Milk: Illness, Health and the Politics of A1 and A2 Milk, Keith Woodford, Chelsea Green Publishing, 2009

Your Soybeans Are Better For You When There’s Not Tons Of Weedkiller In Them, John Upton, Pacific Standard, June 14 2017